Sharing Our Amazing Customer Feedback

Historic Key West Vacation Rentals is sharing our amazing customer feedback so you'll know just what to expect when it's time for your visits!  We take pride in our customer contact opportunities, correspondence with our guests, interactions and the feedback we receive.  How do you know you'll be well taken care of when you stay with us? Just read what our past guests had to say.

A wonderful peaceful oasis tucked away a mere stone's throw away from Duval Street and the many restaurants, shopping and activities. The images of the interior of the home are spot on. Staying here was a Royal treat! - Cloud 9 Guests

Peaceful Oasis in the Heart of Key West: Bright, clean home, quiet during our stay. Ample kitchen and outdoor patio space for grilling and enjoying meals together. The hot tub was a major bonus- great to soak and relax with a drink for a night in. The location was perfect. Everything was in a walkable or bikeable distance. I’d love to stay here again on my next visit. - Guests of Poinciana Garden

5 STARS Best of Key West: Perfect property for a little bit of everything - Sun, history, nightlife, fabulous food all close by. The unit was well appointed and very clean. We loved the dipping pool for some afternoon quiet, reading...and napping with opportunities for sun and shade as needed. Moon Dog Cafe and Blackfin are both right around the corner - both excellent! The staff was helpful and made everything easy. Loved it! - Martha Truman Suite Guests 

A great place to stay. We stayed here for our fifth anniversary, we had never been to Key West before. This place had a great location, just close enough to Duvall but far enough away to avoid the crowds. We had everything we needed in the unit-even beach towels. The cottage was clean, and although we spent most of our time exploring key west and having fun when we came back to the cottage, it was very peaceful. We loved sitting out on the front porch with a cup of coffee in the morning. - Guests of John Truman Hideaway 

Excellent Vacation Home. If you want to stay in a typical Key West conch home this is the place to be! This was a family vacation and it was very nice to have four bedrooms with their own bathrooms. The interior of the home was comfortable, nicely decorated, and very spacious. The exterior porch and pool area gave plenty of room for sun and shade. We have stayed in Key West for 50 years and I loved this location- easy walk or bike ride to anywhere on the Island. We only use bikes, but if you did have a car the private parking is a huge bonus. Historic Key West Vacation Rentals was professional and took care of the one minor request we had. Worth every penny! - Villa Josine Guests 

5 STARS Spring Break Spectacular! The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: Enjoyed Potters cottage very much. The central location is easy to walk to the majority of landmarks on the island. We were a party of five and the layout of the cottage works great did not feel cramped at all. Both the front porch and the back deck with the pool were utilized every day. Again wonderful stay, thanks for the memories! - Guests of Potter's Cottage 

Butterfly Cottage is ideal in every way! It’s well-appointed! The outdoor patio area is beautiful! I enjoyed the hot tub! The linens are very comfortable! The kitchen tools were more than sufficient for cooking and entertaining! The cottage is a 5!!!
I loved staying here!!! Thanks! - Guests of Butterfly Cottage 

 5 STARS Awesome place. Great spot, really enjoyed the vibe of the place. Indoor & Outdoor seating areas a plus. The location was A+, one door off Duval Street! - Guests of Chick-A-Pea Cottage

Now we'd love to hear from you! Spring and summer are already very busy this year, but there's still room for you, too. Choose your luxury boutique vacation rental from our online collection or give our Vacation Planners a call.  We've got lots to talk about!