305-296-1010 Key West, FL
Book by phone: (305) 296-1010

Southard Comfort: Historic Old Town and Seaport, Private Pool & Parking

Guest Rating:

Vacation rental house. Sleeps 6, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms. No pets allowed.

1119 Southard Street Key West, FL 33040 United States

“Southard Comfort” is true Island living in downtown Historic Old Town Key West.

Two story, 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath plus outdoor shower

Nancy & Carl welcome you to their Key West vacation home! This established rental is a dazzling property, and we are committed to continuing its reputation of excellence.

Located just 6 blocks to Duval Street and 4 blocks to the Historic Seaport. This home has off street parking for two vehicles, and you will be able to walk to local restaurants, galleries, the beach, and nightlife!

There are many vacation homes in Key West, but none captures the unique charm of life in Key West like this beautiful home on Southard Street. This is much more than a place to stay; it’s living the Key West experience to the fullest. When you walk into the living room, you’re just a few steps from the pool with its custom waterfall. The expansive French doors can be left open to make the most of those tropical breezes. On really warm days, close up and relax with the central air conditioning. As you look around, you’ll be struck by the fact that this is a home designed for comfort and relaxation. One space flows right into the other, from the inside to the outside, from the living room to the kitchen.

In the kitchen you will find a gas range and ample granite counter tops. You have 3 dining options, dine al fresco by the pool just through the French doors of the kitchen, dine at the granite center island, or in the formal dining room for family meals.

The first floor half bath is large and has a beautiful stone sink. The front loading washer and dryer are conveniently located here with plenty of space for folding.

Take the stairs to the 2nd floor. The master bedroom with a King bed and en suite bathroom, is itself an experience. Each bedroom has its own TV with cable. The second and third bedrooms have Queen beds and share a central bathroom with twin vanities and a full claw foot tub. Sleep with the soft tropical breezes or enjoy the central air conditioning. Once again, every detail and furnishing reminds you that this is Key West, and you are living the life of a local while you are here.

Your stay at Southard Comfort would not be complete without enjoying the private outdoor shower. You can start your day with a relaxing shower under the tropical morning sun or end your day showering under the evening stars. It is also perfect for rinsing off the beach sand or ocean salt.

Digital cable TV with expanded service and high-speed Internet access are included.

Rooms and Amenities
Property Type House, 2 story
Unit Code 1119
Beds 1 king bed, 2 queen beds
Bathrooms 2.5 bathrooms, Powder Room, Clawfoot Tub - Hand Held Shower, Double Vanities, Multi Head Shower System, Walk in Shower, Outdoor Shower
Rooms Sleeps 6
Pets No pets allowed.
Standard Amenities king, queen, toilet, tub, cinemas, coin laundry, festivals, library, live theater, marina, museums, recreation center, reefs, restaurants, synagogues, Satellite / Cable, Television, Air Conditioning, Clothes Dryer, Hair Dryer, Heating, Internet, Iron & Board, Linens Provided, Living Room, Parking, Towels Provided, Washing Machine, Coffee Maker, Dishes & Utensils, Dishwasher, Kitchen, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stove, Toaster, antiquing, beachcombing, bird watching, eco tourism, paddle boating, photography, scenic drives, sight seeing, ATM/bank, fitness center, groceries, hospital, laundromat, massage therapist, medical services, Downtown, Deck / Patio, Lanai / Gazebo, Lawn / Garden, Outdoor Grill, Heated Pool, Private Pool, basketball court, cycling, deepsea fishing, fishing, fly fishing, golf, jet skiing, pier fishing, roller blading, sailing, scuba diving or snorkeling, snorkeling, swimming, tennis, water skiing, children welcome, non smoking only, pets not allowed, wheelchair inaccessible, Minimum Age Limit for Renters
Kitchen Full Kitchen, Granite Counter Tops, Coffee Maker, Refrigerator with Freezer, Ice Maker, Gas Stove, Dishwasher, Microwave, Toaster, Blender, Cookware, Dinnerware
Living Central Air, Air Conditioning, Ceiling Fans, Linens, Washer & Dryer, Ironing Board, WiFi High Speed Internet, Iron, Hairdryer, TV in Living Room, TV in Master Bedroom, TV in Second Bedroom, TV in Third Bedroom
Nearby Convenience Gym, Medical Services, Grocery, Shopping, Movie Theatres, Golf Course, Coffee Shop, Restaurants, 5 Brothers Cuban Coffee Shop, Fausto's Grocery Store, Cole's Peace Bakery, Sunbeam Market, Nightlife Bars Entertainment
Culture Symphony Orchestra, Hemingway House, Tropic Cinema, San Carlos Theatre, Downtown Shopping and Boutiques, Mallory Square Sunsets, Waterfront Theatre Playhouse, Red Barn Theatre Play House, Key West Aquarium, Mel Fisher Treasure Museum, Sound Check at the Green Parrot, Ghost Tours, Conch Tour Train, Butterfly Conservatory, The Studio's of Key West
Outdoor Private Heated Pool, Private Pool, Deck, Front Porch, Private Yard, Gas Grill, Covered Outdoor Lounge Area, Rocking Chairs, Outdoor Dining, Two parking spaces
Geographic Historic Seaport District, Historic Old Town, .7 miles to Duval Street, 9 minute drive to Smather's Beac
Entertainment Cable TV, WiFi High Speed Internet
Average Manager Rating (Based on 345 reviews)

Overall satisfaction

Services from rental manager
Average Vacation Rental Rating (Based on 19 reviews)

Overall satisfaction

Cleanliness

Location

Property condition
100 % of our reviewers would recommend this vacation rental.

Vacation Rental Reviews

  • Vacation within a vacation

    Stayed 3 days ending in July, 2017

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Jesse P from Boynton Beach, FL recommends this vacation rental

    No lie our business group enjoyed all the amenities along with the night life of course. The property's location was perfect. It was a short walk to the strip and great cafe on the way. Not to mention a 4 star restaurant emidiatly around the corner. As for the far excursions we just ubered no more than a 2 min wait. And once we got back to the beautifully decorated house is when our second vacation started. We could communicate with our party from the pool to the kitchen and living room and with the fountain running just topped it off. Super clean house. I want to buy this house just the way it is and I wouldn't change a thing. Btw we got lucky and there was ice cold beer in the fridge when we arrived which helped with the time to get settled in. ( I'm sure it was from the last people so thank you if you see this ) we will definitely be back. Let me know if decide to sell and anybody can call me to verify truth to this long review

  •  
  • Awesome stay

    Stayed 3 days ending in June, 2017

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Bobby C from Lexington, MA recommends this vacation rental

    Couldn't have asked for a better place to stay. The home owner was more than accomodating. I would highly recommend this vacation rental to anyone visting key west

  •  
  • Second Stay as Great as the First!

    Stayed 7 days ending in June, 2017

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    MaryAnne G from Arlington, VA recommends this vacation rental

    Love everything about this house! It's the 25th visit to the island for my husband and me, and the second time we've stayed at Southard Comfort with our twin teens. Great location, beautiful decor, super kitchen/dining set-up, lovely pool area, spotless from top to bottom, super comfy king bed in the master bedroom, great space overall, great this, great that... I could go on and on. The only downside? Showers are a little unusual (slanted ceiling in master bath is a little short for my 6'3" husband, shared bath for two other bedrooms not ideal for privacy or shower optimization - it's a footed tub with a surround curtain) but that is the only downside... and it's a minor one. I most definitely highly recommend staying here - it's ideal for a family of four - and could easily handle more if you go two-to-a-queen in the two guest bedrooms.

  •  
  • Great Family location

    Stayed 4 days ending in June, 2017

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    a guest from Annandale, VA recommends this vacation rental

    Love He location and the amenities. Was perfect family set up. Had friends that rented the same place right after us. Would highly recommend. Owners stopped by to check on our stay!

  •  
  • Great Stay!

    Stayed 7 days ending in April, 2017

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    a guest from Fishers, IN recommends this vacation rental

    We really enjoyed the location, the property was very clean! The bathrooms were a little difficult for 7 people. The rental company was great! The pool was a great size! We had a great time!

  •  
  • Great house, excellent location...

    Stayed 7 days ending in January, 2017

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    a guest from Williamsburg, VA recommends this vacation rental

    This is our second time staying at Southard Comfort. Each time we have met the owners and they have always been very friendly and engaged. The house is nicely furnished, the kitchen is well equipped, and for a family with children it's perfect. The location is nice because it is close enough to restaurants and shops, but just far enough away to be quiet and off the beaten path. Although it has a parking spot, we have always just rented bikes and pedaled everywhere. Fausto's for groceries is a 5 minute bike ride away. The pool is small, and the area around it is very shady, but it's an otherwise pleasant space. It's nice to have a washer and dryer. My only criticism is that the master bed mattress should be replace. It's soft and lumpy and not comfortable. I have made the property management company aware of this and hope the owner will take action on this for the benefit of future renters. Overall, big thumbs up for Southard Comfort!

    • Manager Responded on 4/7/2017

      Hello David! It was a pleasure to have you and your family stay with us again at Southard Comfort! The owners were very grateful for your feedback and they purchased a new mattress for the master bedroom. We look forward to your next stay with us!

  •  
  • Family Vacation!

    Stayed 7 days ending in November, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Patricia S from Prospect Heights, IL recommends this vacation rental

    It was wonderful! House is gorgeous! Owner and property manager were very receptive! Loved it and will be back.......

    • Manager Responded on 12/10/2016

      Hey Pat! Thanks so taking a moment to post your review from your recent stay with us at Southard Comfort. We're so happy you had a wonderful vacation and thought the house was gorgeous. You are welcome to come back anytime!

  •  
  • Lovely Home!

    Stayed 7 days ending in October, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Jim S from Nashville, TN recommends this vacation rental

    Our weeklong stay at Southard was wonderful. The home is lovely and well suited for families or small groups. Our concierge Phil went above and beyond to help us with our needs while we were there. The owners were very quick to address a very small issue while we were there. Great location that is a short bike ride from Duval Street fun. The heated pool was excellent and all the furniture was very comfortable. We all loved the outdoor shower. The house was well stocked with everything you would need and the owners were kind enough to leave us some small snacks and cold beers to kick off our stay. The house is near several excellent restaurants-- El Siboney, Cafe Sole, Azur, Seven Fish, Mangia Mangia. The one thing I would have people be aware of is that all of the bedrooms are upstairs and the slatted doors on all of the doors (including bathrooms) make it a little less private than I would have preferred. Overall, an excellent property and we would definitely stay there again!

    • Manager Responded on 11/6/2016

      Hi Jim! Thanks for your review from your wonderful week long stay at Southard Comfort. It is Phil's pleasure to ensure you have all that you need in order to enjoy this beautiful island, and your kind comments about him and the owners are greatly appreciated. It sounds like you truly enjoyed the home, its location and amenities. Thanks so much for taking the time to post your review. HKWVR as well as the owners of your vacation rental home, Nancy and Carl, can't wait to have you back!

  •  
  • A Perfect Stay

    Stayed 5 days ending in September, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Sara B from Orange Park, Florida recommends this vacation rental

    We had a wonderful time at Southard Comfort. The location was perfect and we just loved the house. It had everything we needed to have a nice relaxation vacation! I highly recommend Southard Comfort and look forward to staying here in the future!

    • Manager Responded on 10/15/2016

      Hi Sara! Thanks for your review of Southard Comfort. We're so happy you had everything you needed to have a nice relaxation vacation. Please let us know then next time you plan on visiting Key West so we may provide you with another great stay.

  •  
  • Such a wonderful place!

    Stayed 5 days ending in September, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Robert M from Nashville , TN recommends this vacation rental

    Upon arrival we were greeted by Nancy and Carl. In our brief passing you can tell they are such wonderful people. Carls best advice was "dont wait till the last day to check out the outdoor shower". Dang was he right! It was so easy to jump in rinse off and a nice dip in the pool after a day of riding bikes or laying on the beach. It truly made for a magical trip to the Keys. We had a party of 6 and there was plenty of room to move around in the house if you wanted. The veranda and pool were so very nice with an adult beverage after after a day in the high 90 temps. AC AND fans in each room allowed you to get that cool night breeze if you so desired. Also within a 3-4 minute bike ride you could be at no less than 6 different restaurants and 2 markets. So not only is the home itself a gem, inice location.

    • Manager Responded on 10/15/2016

      Hi Robert! Thank you for such a descriptive review from your stay at Southard Comfort. It really sounds like you all had a marvelous time! Nancy, Carl and us here at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals can't wait to have you back. Thanks again for taking the time to post your review.

  •  
  • perfect!

    Stayed 6 days ending in August, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Hillary H from Findlay, OH recommends this vacation rental

    this was the perfect vacation home. the house was beautiful, very clean. private pool was the perfect size for us to hop in and cool off. hardly spent any time inside because of the shaded patio and pool! the outdoor shower was great, none of us showered inside again after the first night. Walking distance to duval, but away from the craziness when you want a break. it definitely was a hard place to leave....

    • Manager Responded on 9/1/2016

      Hi Hillary! Thanks so much for taking the time to post a review. It's great to hear you thought the house was, "beautiful and very clean"! We look forward to having you back again soon.

  •  
  • Fantastic Vacation

    Stayed 7 days ending in July, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Kathie C from Madison, IA recommends this vacation rental

    This was the first time I utilized the Historic Key West Vacation Rentals and must say I was quite pleased with them. They were so good about keeping in touch to see if we needed any other information.

    • Manager Responded on 7/22/2016

      Hi Kathie! Thanks so much for your HKWVR shout out! It's our pleasure to help you enjoy your vacation in Key West. See you next year!

  •  
  • Peaceful Paradise

    Stayed 7 days ending in June, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    John Mark W from Charlotte, NC recommends this vacation rental

    This house is a simple Charm. From the front door to the awesome pool and porch area, you feel as though you are at home, at least for a week !The location was perfect, just far enough away from Duval or Main Street, yet a few blocks to the Marina area. Phil was our concierge for the week, and was very helpful
    especially with the restaurants. This is a must
    return destination for house and of course Key West itself.

  •  
  • Great ocation and wonderful place!

    Stayed 3 days ending in May, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    a guest from Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario recommends this vacation rental

    This is an ideal location to stay while visiting Key West. Close but not too close to all the action. You can walk easily to various things but are far away enough from Duvall to avoid all the noise.

    The house is nicely laid out and has a wonderful side yard. The small pool is perfect for hopping in and cooling off.

  •  
  • Key West Vacation rental

    Stayed 6 days ending in March, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    a guest from Columbus, OH recommends this vacation rental

    Flawless from start to finish. Property exceeded expectations in every way. Concierge was excellent.

  •  
  • Five Stars!

    Stayed 5 days ending in March, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Laine P from Wilmington, DE recommends this vacation rental

    This cottage is stunning! The living room with doors that slide open looking out onto the pool is unmatched! Updated kitchen, laundry, dining room, outdoor shower, 3 spacious bedrooms, etc. is perfect for 4-6 people. Well kept cottage, centrally located in a friendly neighborhood with an impressing number of intimate bars & restaurants for those who need a break from Duval Street, this place has it all! Last but not least, the staff at Historic Key West Vacation Rentals are uber friendly, great communicators and so easy to work with -- really top notch all the way around!

  •  
  • Couples Getaway Extended Unexpectedly

    Stayed 2 days ending in January, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Theresa L from Islip Terrace, NY recommends this vacation rental

    Southard Comfort was wonderful. The decor, location, and amenities were perfect! The staff at Historic Key West were amazing! From bike rentals to restaurant and activities recommendations, they had the answers! When our flight was cancelled due to weather at home, they and the property owners allowed us to stay an additional 2 nights to ease the stress of finding other accommodations! Would stay here again and would recommend to others!

  •  
  • Best Vacation Ever!

    Stayed 5 days ending in January, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    Theresa L from Islip Terrace, NY recommends this vacation rental

    This was the first time I ever rented a house for vacation and it was a wonderful experience.
    The house was beautiful and extremely clean.
    I would definitely do it again. Property management company was so helpful and nice.

  •  
  • Great house, excellent location, would rent again!

    Stayed 7 days ending in January, 2016

    • Services from rental manager
    • Cleanliness
    • Location
    • Property condition

    Overall satisfaction:

    a guest from Williamsburg, VA recommends this vacation rental

    House is nicely furnished, kitchen well equipped, and located in a quiet area of Key West. We didn't even rent a car: just had bikes and could get to grocery stores, restaurants, beaches, etc very easily. Although the pool is very small and shaded by trees, it was nicely heated and used during our week. Phil fro Historic Key West Vaction Rentals was very professional and helpful. Although we didn't need him for much during our stay, it was nice to know he was available in case we had any issues.

  •  
Getting your rate Getting your rate...
1. Select Your Dates to Check Availability

Click calendar to set checkin/checkout dates. clear calendar

 Unavailable  Selected  Available  Checkin only  Checkout only
2. Review Dates and Rates

Select/Confirm the number of travelers to get a rate quote.

: :
Base Rent:
Fees & Taxes:*
Total Price:
:
:
*Click 'Continue Booking' to view details of fees & taxes

Seasonal Rental Rates for this Vacation Rental

Dates Daily Weekly Monthly Minimum Stay Checkin Restrictions
Oct 1, 2017-Dec 31, 2017 $595-$1,294 $3,965-$7,504 $17,000-$24,305 1 No restrictions
Jan 1, 2018-Apr 30, 2018 $890-$961 $6,030-$6,386 $24,200-$24,556 5 No restrictions
May 1, 2018-Sep 30, 2018 $683-$793 $4,250-$4,910 $16,900-$17,890 3 No restrictions
Oct 1, 2018-Dec 28, 2018 $770-$1,046 $5,230-$7,162 $21,100-$24,722 5 No restrictions

*Seasonal rates are estimates only. Actual rates may differ. Seasonal rates do not include fees or taxes.

To request information about booking this vacation rental, please fill out the form below.


Sorry, we encountered the following error(s):

  • Unable to process request.
loading Sending Email...
Your email has been sent successfully!

Sorry, we encountered the following error(s):

  • Unable to process request.
loading Sending Email...
Your email has been sent successfully!
24.559703,-81.7946

Historic Key West Vacation Rentals 425 Eaton Street Key West, FL 33040 (305) 296-1010 bookings@historickw.com

© 1999 - 2017 | Powered By Escapia Vacation Rental Software | Terms of Use

Logon